Showing posts with label perfectly acceptable logic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label perfectly acceptable logic. Show all posts

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Logic In Its Purest Form

            (Okay, as it turns out, I had to delay this next post for quite a while. So what? It’s not like you’re doing anything that great. Look at you, staring at a computer screen when you could be designing a skyscraper or giving CPR to a puppy or making a sandwich or something. Everybody knows that every moment not spent making a sandwich is a moment wasted.)

            An actual conversation that I recently had with my brother:

Brother: So, anyway, I’m going to watch Killers on my Netflix account…
Me: Wait, what?
Brother: What?
Me: That’s a romantic comedy!
Brother: No it’s not. Netflix says that it’s an action-comedy.
Me: Of course it says that. That’s how you know it’s a bad romantic comedy, because it tries to disguise itself as something else. The good ones are at least up front about being drivel. If it says it’s not a romantic comedy, that means it’s a really bad one.
Brother: Or, it could mean that it isn’t a romantic comedy.
Me: Ridiculous. Every movie that tries to market itself as something other than a romantic comedy is obviously just denying its true nature.
Brother: And the ones that do market themselves as romantic comedies?
Me: Are romantic comedies, obviously.
Brother: So every movie is a romantic comedy?
Me: Exactly.
Brother: So, if the only good romantic comedies are the ones that market themselves as romantic comedies, and every movie is a romantic comedy, then the only good movies are the ones that say they’re romantic comedies?
Me: I didn’t say we lived in an ideal world.
Brother: I’m not sure I buy this theory. Are you saying that 2001: A Space Odyssey is a romantic comedy?
Me: An unconventional one, but yes. Are you saying you detected no romantic tension between Dr. Floyd and the monolith? Between Dave and HAL? Between that Australopithecus and its stick?
Brother: (Audible silence. I’m not quite sure how he managed to do that, actually.)
Me: What?
Brother: …Okay, what about Pirates of the Caribbean?
Me: A torrid romance between a sailor and his love, the sea, who can never be together because one of them is from a low social standing and the other is 70% of the world’s surface.
Brother: Thor?
Me: You look at the way he grips that hammer and tell me you don’t notice any chemistry.
Brother: The Other Guys?
Me: Of course. That’s a bromance, which is “romance” with a “B”. So according to the United States educational system, a bromance is just a romance that has passed with a minimum of 83%
Brother: Passed what?
Me: I’m not quite sure. You can’t expect me to figure everything out for you.